Arrowhead Lake

STR and Vacation Homes for Sale. Arrowhead Lake Community Association is a private, gated community in Pocono Lake, PA

Arrowhead Lake

This is a Yellow Scorecard Community

ARROWHEAD LAKE (Coolbaugh Township and Tobyhanna Township, PA)
As one of the area’s most recognized vacation home communities, Arrowhead Lake has a rich tradition of vacation rentals. There are over 2,450 Member-owned houses and 850 lots, a total of 4,330 propert ies in the community. As of March 2020, roughly 20-25% of the homes in Arrowhead were owned and occupied by full-time residents, the vast majority of are vacation homes and the number of rentals in the community is rising. Renters love this Golf cart friendly gated community, which feels like a resort with its nice amenities including multiple pools and beaches. Read more about Renting your home in Arrowhead Lake. About half of Arrowhead is in Tobyhanna Township which recently imposed a cap on the number of short term rentals licenses. Due to the uncertainties surrounding license issuance, caution is advised when purchasing in Tobyhanna Township. See vacation homes for sale in Arrowhead Lake.

February 19, 2025
All Articles, STR SCORECARDS

Top 10 STR-Friendly Communities in the Poconos

Top 10 STR Friendly Communities in the PoconosMention HOA and many people think of cumbersome...

by markshayrealtor

July 3, 2023
All Articles, STR SCORECARDS

Short-term Rental Friendly Pocono Communities

Some communities are more friendly to VRBO and Airbnb, others oppose the practice. Here is an...

by markshayrealtor

Scroll through listings in Arrowhead Lake

Contact Mark shay to find your vacation property in the poconos

Testimonials

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipisicing

"Mark was really great! He was very knowledgeable about the area and key to us picking the right neighborhood to search for our vacation home. He was extremely helpful in ensuring that we could look at places on our limited time schedule and with our little kiddos! He kept in touch throughout the process and continues to reach out to make sure everything is going smoothly."

Andrew Peckham

Bought a Single Family Home, Albrightsville, PA

Mark Shay made the purchase of my new STR in Jim Thorpe almost effortless. Based on my criteria, he had a list of homes to choose from within an hour of my request. I am not from the area, so Mark connected me with vendors and helped me safely navigate the STR licensing process. Mark shay is a great realtor and the ambassador for the Poconos mountain community and I highly recommend him for your home purchase journey.

Samuel Everett

Jim Thorpe, PA

When it was still definitely a seller's market, Mark found our ideal spot in the Poconos where we could start our Short Term Rental venture. He gave that extra touch to make sure our bid was complete and won! Thanks Mark and hope to obtain more properties in the Poconos with you.

Jcarmody73

Bought a Single Family home in 2022 in Pocono Lake, PA

Highly recommend! Fantastic Realtor with extensive knowledge. I am a first time home buyer and he was a huge help every step of the way. He helped me find my vacation/investment home in a wonderful lake community.

Susan perez01

Bought a Single family home in 2022 in Albrightsville

Unlock the Potential of Poconos Real Estate with Expert Guidance

Mark Shay is a trusted real estate professional specializing in short-term rental properties in the Poconos. With comprehensive knowledge of township and HOA laws and regulations, he ensures clients navigate the complexities of the market with ease. Whether you’re investing in a vacation rental or searching for the perfect retreat, Mark’s expertise and personalized approach make him the ideal partner for your real estate journey.